It’s been many years since I read John Steinbeck’s hugely
ambitious, hugely powerful, East of Eden. This sprawling family saga,
from 1952, was the mature Steinbeck’s longest and most ambitious novel,
intended to contain truly biblical implications. It’s the story of two
generations of the Trask family, each of which re-enacts in some way the story
of Adam and Eve’s mismatched sons Cain and Abel, who were fated to participate
in one another’s destruction.
The novel was a huge success in its own day, and led to a
major 1955 film, directed by Elia Kazan. James Dean led the large cast; this
was to be the only one of his three major films that opened during his brief
lifetime. (He died at age 24 when his Porsche 550 Spyder was
struck by another driver on a California highway.) But true Steinbeck
afficionados of course noted that the film covers only one of the novel’s four
sections, the climactic tale of brothers Cal and Aron in the early part of the
20th century, as the U.S. is entering the first World War. The
backstory of their father, Adam, and his own brother Charles is left out, as is
the very complicated involvement of their mysterious mother, Cathy.
I was impressed to learn that the talented young actress Zoe
Kazan had recently decided to take on the job of adapting the entire novel into
a TV miniseries. Unlike her grandfather,
Elia Kazan, she was determined to cover several generations of the Trask
family, focusing in particular on Cathy as both a young wife and as a
middle-aged woman who’d abandoned her husband and twin sons in order to live a
life free from both family obligations and conventional morality. Rising star
Florence Pugh took on this key role, while also serving as one of the series’
executive producers. I was excited to see how Kazan and company had tackled the
complex story, but one evening’s worth of watching left me reluctant to go
further. (The word “lugubrious” comes to mind.) Instead, I returned to the
classic Hollywood film, and was very glad I did.
The 1955 film is set almost entirely in Steinbeck’s beloved
Salinas Valley, a short ride by rail to the rocky Northern California
coastline. In the fertile countryside the pious Adam Trask (the always
impressive Raymond Massey) raises vegetables, and also two vastly different
twin sons. Richard Davalos as Aron is studious and moral, while Cal (played by
Dean) is an angry but shrewd misfit. Two women complicate the brothers’
lives: Jo Van Fleet won a Supporting
Actress Oscar for playing the boys’ errant mother, whose true identity Cal
discovers early on. I was particularly taken by Julie Harris as the girlish but
quietly rebellious Abra, who expects to marry Aron but belatedly discovers an
affinity with his brother.
Yet it is Dean’s performance that overshadows all the
others. He conveys a powerful sense of self-hatred and loss in this, as in the
slightly later Rebel Without a Cause and Giant. It’s easy to
compare him to Brando and especially to the earlier Montgomery Clift, whose
life and tragic decline somewhat matched Dean’s own trajectory (though Clift
lived almost twice as long). Perhaps no other actor conveys adolescent pain as
powerfully as James Dean. I cannot speak to the skill of the actor playing Cal
in Zoe Kazan’s East of Eden miniseries: his character was far from being
born in the single episode I watched. I know, though, that Dean’s work in the
1955 film has a power I’ll never forget.
No comments:
Post a Comment