I’m just back from a week in Washington, DC. To my surprise,
the nation’s capital currently seems a lot more bipartisan than I would have
guessed. Yes, there were giant Trump portraits hanging from some prominent
government buildings. But I also saw a major Washington boulevard shut down on
behalf of a wild and crazy Gay Pride festival. And overt dissent was on display
nearby: outside a tent manned by some dedicated anti-Trumpers, I spotted a
large placard that gave MAGA a new definition: Make Algae Great Again.
Washington’s wonderful Smithsonian museums (open daily and
free to all comers) seemed as welcoming and as even-handed as ever, pointing up
our nation’s failings but also its glories.
Some of the city’s private museums, though, were clearly interested in
viewing today’s deep political divide in the context of past eras that were
equally contentious. That certainly seemed part of the reason the Capital
Jewish Museum is now hosting an exhibit called “Blacklisted: An American
Story.” Its focus is on the era—starting in 1947 and lasting until the early
Sixties—when the House Un-American Activities Committee was terrorizing
Hollywood, forcing the major studios to remove from their ranks anyone (Jewish
or otherwise) who had ever been sympathetic to the Communist party. (The only
way to return to the film industry’s good graces in that era was to dish up the
names of others whose politics were—or had ever been—suspect.)
As part of this exhibit, the museum showed a series of film
clips relevant to the blacklist period. Two of the films were directed by Elia
Kazan. Gentleman’s Agreement (1947) makes a brave argument against the
built-in anti-Semitism of that era; the clip from On the Waterfront
(1954) shows Marlon Brando as a longshoreman and would-be boxer climatically
choosing to risk everything by bringing a mob boss to justice. Because Kazan
was infamously known as one of those who “named names” to save his own career,
many in Hollywood never forgave him. Orson Welles, for one, disparaged the
latter film as “a celebration of the informant.”
Three films written by Dalton Trumbo are also included in
this montage. Two are from 1960, when the once-disgraced Trumbo was finally
able to resume getting on-screen credit for his work. After writing Spartacus,
he was championed by star Kirk Douglas, to whom he said, “Thanks, Kirk, for
giving me back my name.” On earlier Trumbo films that appeared during the
blacklist era, Trumbo had had to submit each of his scripts under a fictive monicker,
or that of another writer. The screenwriting Oscar he won in 1954 for crafting
under an assumed name the delightful (and totally apolitical) Roman Holiday was
not awarded to him until 1993, almost three decades after his death.
The exhibit also focuses on the sad example of John
Garfield, one of many actors whose careers (and lives) were destroyed during
the blacklist years. Garfield (born Jacob Garfinkle on New York’s Lower East
Side) was a longtime supporter of liberal causes. He began appearing in major
Hollywood films in 1938, usually in blue-collar roles, and was twice nominated
for Oscars, notably for his lead role in the 1947 boxing film, Body and
Soul. But his refusal to speak against his wife (once a member of the
Communist Party) as well as his unwillingness to provide the House committee
with the names of other Hollywood “Reds” ultimately destroyed him. He died of a
heart attack in 1932 at the age of 39, just after a dream project in which he
was to star was abruptly cancelled.
Despite it all, Happy 4th of July!
 |
| John Garfield, with quote from his daughter |
