In this country, we’re fast
approaching the every-four-years Silly Season, when candidates go to insane
extremes to convince voters not to support their opponents. (Given the nature
of the 2024 U.S. presidential candidates and their proxies, insanity is truly
the name of the game.) Last evening, I decided to turn away from political
realities by watching a 1993 film that finds great humor and heart in a presidential what-if.
In Dave, which came
out in the year of Schindler’s List, Kevin Kline plays U.S. President
Bill Mitchell, a cold-hearted man with
an eye for pretty young bed-warmers. It bothers him not one whit that his
behavior has permanently estranged the First Lady (Sigourney Weaver), who only
pretends to be part of a happy presidential couple. But his misbehavior catches
up with him when, in bed with a cute member of his staff, he suffers a severe
stroke. His cagey chief of staff (the always-slightly-reptilian Frank Langella)
has no wish to undermine his own power by handing the reins of government over
to the squeaky-clean vice-president (Ben Kingsley, of all people).l His
solution is to elevate a convenient look-alike (also, of course, played by
Kevin Kline) into the presidency. Kline’s Dave, who runs a Georgetown temp
agency, is naturally at first awed by the honor of pretending to be President
Mitchell. He’s naïve about the personalities of the powers that be, and
overwhelmed by the thrill of actually occupying the presidential suite in the
White House. (When he lifts up a phone receiver to make a call from the Oval
Office, he feels the need to ask if he needs to dial 9 first.)
But Dave, for all his
aw-shucks manner, is not exactly a fool. He believes in his country’s mission,
sees true honor in helping the genuinely needy, and quickly discovers that as
President Mitchell he’s positioned to do an end-run around his malevolent chief
of staff. There comes a time, though, when the situation of a missing,
ailing president has to be permanently
resolved. And Dave’s inventive solution, which I’m sure takes most viewers
completely by surprise, allows for a happy ending that’s at least semi-credible,
given all that’s gone before.
It's well known that comedies,
even excellent ones, are generally overlooked when Oscars are handed out. The
year of Schindler’s List also produced a number of other seriously great
films, like The Remains of the Day, The Age of Innocence, and Philadelphia,
the AIDS-related drama for which Tom Hanks won his first Oscar. Dave was nominated for exactly one Academy
Award, a well-deserved nod to Gary Ross for his original screenplay, which
beautifully sets up all the craziness to come. (As a longtime teacher of
screenwriting. I salute him.) The screenwriting Oscar, though, went to Jane
Campion, for her extraordinarily inventive work on The Piano. (Other
losers in that category were Ron Nyswaner for writing Philadelphia and
Nora Ephron—among others—for scripting a romcom classic, Sleepless in
Seattle.)
Politics American-style is a
funny business. The year of Dave’s release into theatres was also the
year that William Jefferson Clinton entered the White House. When the threat of
a presidential impeachment arose in Dave, audiences of the time were
well aware that a U.S. president had never been impeached since Andrew Johson
in 1868. That was to change in 1998 following the notorious Monica Lewinsky
affair, and of course we all know which president was impeached twice during his
single term in office.
What’s going on our country
today is no laughing matter. But I’m grateful that Dave finds some humor
in unthinkable news from Washington.