Jonathan Demme’s Melvin
and Howard is a small movie about small people, unless you count reclusive zillionaire
Howard Hughes, whose massive shadow hangs over the whole enterprise. Dennis
Bingham's Whose Lives Are They Anyway? The Biopic as Contemporary Film Genre
cites Melvin and Howard as the first film in the subgenre "biopic
of someone undeserving.” The undeserving someone in this case is Melvin Dummar,
the Utah man who, after Hughes’ death in 1976, popped up as a major beneficiary
of Hughes’ vast estate by way of a mysterious handwritten will unearthed at the
headquarters of the Mormon Church in Salt Lake City. The so-called Mormon Will
was eventually judged a blatant forgery. But through a number of court hearings
Dummar continued to insist that he’d rescued Hughes in the Nevada desert in
1967, giving a needy old man a friendly lift to Las Vegas.
Melvin and Howard is a fanciful riff on that slice of history, taking
Dummar’s story at face value. (Hollywood veteran Bo Goldman won an original
screenplay Oscar for his lively telling of the tale.) It begins with a scruffy
and maniacal Howard Hughes (played with
his usual panache by Jason Robards) gleefully racing his chopper through the
desert, before the fun ends with a spectacular crash. Hours later, garage
mechanic Dummar happens along in his truck, stops to take a leak, and discovers
the fallen tycoon. Throughout their ride, Hughes remains taciturn and cranky,
until the chatty Dummar gets him to singing a favorite old song, “Bye Bye,
Blackbird.” At journey’s end, after Hughes reveals his identity (and borrows
some cash), they go their separate ways.
The bulk of the film is a
portrait of Dummar (well played by Paul Le Mat) as a perennial dreamer, someone
who can’t hold down a job but is convinced that happy days are just around the
corner. He loves wife Lynda (the adorably ditsy Mary Steenburgen in her Oscar-winning
role), but can’t quite seem to provide a stable life. The centerpiece of the
film is the on-again off-again marriage of these two: at one point she leaves
him and their daughter to work in a topless bar. Their fortunes seem to turn
when he gets Lynda onto a talent-and-game show in which (despite her
tap-dancing ineptitude) she wins a large sum of money, all of which Melvin
quickly squanders. The romantic allure of money, as seen in this segment, is at this film’s very heart. The show is called Easy Street, and its
smarmy host alternates between sexual innuendo and a worshipful attitude toward
big bucks. It seems all too apt that Lynda’s tap routine is performed to the
Rolling Stones’ “Satisfaction.”
If you’re Melvin Dummar—a
laid-back guy convinced that life on Easy Street awaits if only you believe
hard enough—it’s perfectly likely that Howard Hughes would leave you a fortune.
The question of the mysterious will continued to dog the real Dummar’s life,
which ended in 2018. Melvin and Howard, though, concludes long before
that, returning to the footage of two unlikely buddies, an old man and a young
one, joyfully belting out an old musical-hall tune.
I worked briefly with
Jonathan Demme in 1974, when he’d just returned from directing his first film, Caged
Heat, for Roger Corman’s New World Pictures. He moved on to some studio
gigs, but Melvin and Howard was his true breakthrough, showing off his
skill at capturing American life and moving him toward the big pictures, like
1991’s The Silence of the Lambs. (I’ll mention in passing his sharp ear
for musical scoring.) Unfortunately he left us much too soon.